Skip to Main Content

University Library

LibGuides

Evidence Synthesis & Systematic Reviews in Medicine and Health

How to conduct Systematic Reviews, Scoping Reviews and more

 

Scoping Review

A Scoping Review is an initial exploratory search and synthesis of an emerging  research area, or a broad, multifaceted,  or multi-question research topic.
 

Goals/Objectives:

  • Characterize  breadth, depth, and nature of research in a topic area
  • Identify methodologies or theoretical frameworks
  • Reveal gaps in research (precursor for Systematic Review)

 

A scoping review requires:

  • Clear objectives for the study
  • Reproducible methodology
  • Comprehensive search appropriate for time/scope constraints
  • Data extraction and synthesis of the quantity and quality of literature
  • Written review reporting characteristics and findings from literature corpus

Scoping Review Standards

Scoping Review Elements

  • Title
  • Objectives
  • Question(s)
  • Inclusion/Exclusion Criteria
    • Population
    • Concept
    • Context
    • Types of evidence source
  • Evidence source Details and Characteristics
    • Citation details (author, date, title, journal, volume, issue, pages)
    • County
    • Context
    • Participants (age/sex/number)
  • Details/Results extracted from source of evidence

SOURCE: JBI Appendix 11.1 JBI template source of evidence details, characteristics and results extraction instrument

Doing Scoping Reviews